[mim3 comments: The below came after Magistra Tani Jantsang branded MIM or at least mim3 enemy for not turning over a source on Lysenko that also talks about MEC. There was a few lengthy tirades from Tani on the subject.] replies to Tani [These written before I read "last one." See the problem with "private science" is that it invents reasons to brand enemies, which is the whole point of strife-torn religions on behalf of the ruling class as well. See now making a comment about a secondary reference on Lysenko becomes a reason for this persyn to brand enemy! Hah! If you can't see why MIM holds the line against solipsism by now, you are never going to see it. It leads to INFINITE Hobbessian division. For crying out loud, divide over something else, like opposing NAFTA or wanting better jobs for whitey like you have been crying. Solipsism is doomed. The word is out on COINTELPRO and ruling class tactics of creating division. The only question is whether the solipsists will take the species with them.] Wrong again, MIM has covered some of the struggle within the Church, and in more than one country. Right, fine to infiltrate IF you have the anti-klippoth vaccine. Otherwise, once again you pay the price. You know it's too bad you don't read Lenin, because you would know that MIM is also better than these other groups like PL for another reason. We understand what you are saying and some things Stalin had to do: PL and the Trots ONLY want reds to be straight-forward. They are infiltrated by the labor aristocracy and Christianity to MAKE US LOSE. If you could come up with the vaccine or nutritional injection to solve religion, then maybe TOD would be more important than mode of production (MOPs). Still, then the bourgeoisie would ALSO become more scientific on average and might pursue it's interests more effectively. Surely though, the proletariat has more to gain from such a bio solution. The thing about Egypt and TOS, obviously we don't give a shit about that, such a small circle with such delusional ideas. Too much theory, too easily could have been some other delusion. We ain't gonna give the TOD any points for that. "Perhaps what you DO NOT want to see is that little tiny seed that DID develop and GROW INTO the monster imperialism you see right under your noses now....because the only way to stop it would BE to pull it out by its roots and you can't do that, you don't even advocate that." OK, it says the same thing we are saying IF it turns out true that say an injection of nutrients is the straight away solution. Then it would just be a matter of biological materialism making a more important contribution than political science. Are you happy? But we have also said to you before that on this we may be more Lysenkoite than Granny. Look, it may be that focussing in on MOPs does MORE to alter biology than sitting around waiting for the anti-klippoth drug to appear. Go read *FASTING GIRLS.* See people's biology in anorexia changes for SOCIAL reasons. Could there be anything more persuasive than PREDICTING the willingness to DIE from self-imposed starvation from the MOP? Huh? Political economy trumps bio. Now sure if I were only saying people's internal body temperature goes down one degree from living in imperialist countries, well maybe so what? But if it turns out that there is a predictable pattern of DEATH confined to certain social groups, then why the hell do I need biological materialism for that? See and that is not even STARTING to fuck with your reasoning by talking about WHY the ruling class pharmaceuticals and medical profession WILL NOT be pursuing the solution to widespread brain damage. Let's look at what is holding them back! So once again, why TOD and not MOP? If we are saying the SAME thing Tani, then you should give up your role as challenger and work within MOP, because MOP has been around longer and is known by more people--unless your whole POINT is "private science" and being intellectuals for division's sake. Again though, I would not change the COS. You have your ways. The question will always be whether you wake up more fascists than you slay. -------------------- Tani: I'll comment: it would not be hard at all to have a, DEJURE, communist system, a DEJURE gender-equal system with men in it that STILL HAD THESE DESIRES/FEARS and women in it AS PENT UP as they are in the west. It would be all DEJURE and not DEFACTO at all. And DEFACTO pedophiles would DEJURE watch their actions 100% of the time OR ELSE face the gun or gulag or worse. THIS is NOT a change at all. It's a BAND AID used to cover up a CANCER. And we could have DEJURE non-racism with DEFACTO racism waiting to explode in genocide at the LEAST HINT of slackening of the ARMED anti-racist-patrols. MIM3: We agree with that. That's why we have to keep moving forward in other areas too, advancing the productive forces, medical advances.