Tracking Prison Censorship in the United States

DENIED BY OII FOR STG by McCann

also cites and (15)(p) otherwise presents a threat to the security, order or rehabilitation objectives of the correctional system or the safety of any person.

Page 35: any prisoner actively opposing revolution should be eliminated ASAP
Page 38: revolutionary action gave rise to an alternate political, ethical and moral universe where established terms like "murder" and "killing" failed to convey the meaning of taking lives that many believed deserved to be taken.
The whole publication uses past violence to justify future rebellion.

May 22, 2024

ATTN: Library Services Administrator
Department of Corrections
501 South Calhoun Street
Tallahassee, FL 32399-2500

Re: Notification of Rejection or Impoundment of Publications

To Whom It May Concern:

We are in receipt of your censorship notice for the publication Tip of the Spear sent to one XXXXXX XXXXXX DC#XXXXXX at Santa Rosa Correctional Institution, dated April 2, 2024, which we received on May 10, 2024. A copy of this notice is enclosed within.

The listed reason for censorship is that Tip of the Spear allegedly violates sections (15)(i) and (15)(p) of Rule 33-501.401, FAC in that it “is dangerously inflammatory in that it advocates or encourages riot, insurrection, rebellion, organized prison protest, disruption of the institution, or the violation of federal law, state law, or Department rules” and/or “otherwise presents a threat to the security, order, or rehabilitative objectives of the correctional system.” Furthermore, the notice lists two excerpts from pages 35 and 38 to support these allegations.

As distributors of Tip of the Spear, we know that no material fitting any criteria of the above description can be found anywhere in the publication. The book describes a significant historical event that occurred in the context of a correctional facility in the United States, but in no way does this description “advocate or encourage” acts of riot or rebellion. As for the aforementioned excerpts, one is a quote from a prisoner who participated in the Attica riot and one is a description by the author of the riot participants’ mindsets at the time. This is obviously an inane basis on which to censor the publication as it is akin to censoring a historical work which focuses on World War II for being antisemitic merely for mentioning the Holocaust or Nazi Germany.

We request the decision to withhold Tip of the Spear be vacated and the publication be forwarded to Mr. XXXXXX. Failure to provide appropriate notice and adherence to your policies may result in legal action.

Please govern yourself accordingly.


Sincerely,

"Suspected drug laced paper sent in via mail"

Sometime in April the prisoner was pulled out of the law library and questioned in the shakedown room by Institutional Investigator Cochran. I.I. had test the mail for drugs and it came up negative. The prisoner pointed out that it was clearly ink from the paper being folded and mailed and I.I. staff agreed.

1. Copy of original confiscated letter by I.I. on 3/21/2024 from MIM Publishers to be preserved for litigation.
2. Camera footage from I.I.'s shakedown room with me from April 17, 2024 7am-9am
3. I want test results preserved from the 3/21/24 letter that was confiscated.

"The confiscation sheet is attached for your records and will be scanned with this into your file. OII has preserved the video of the interview, and you were also explained the process in the interview. The item was tested and determined not to be a narcotic and the item was given back to you."

To preserve the Original letter from MIM Distributors that I.I. confiscated on 3/21/24 citing it was drug laced. I.I. released a copy of the letter to me on April 17, 2024, telling me that it was tested and results came back negative. Charges of trafficking were dismissed. This original letter will show it only contained smeared ink on the letter from the print, folded and mailed 2000 miles. The original letter is needed for litigation in case NO. 1:23-cv.01964-JRS.TAB

Prisoner reports appeal denied by Facility Media Review Committee because pages 79 through 90 "advocates acts of violence"

February 4, 2024

Mohawk Correctional Facility
ATTN: Facility Media Review Committee
6514 Rte 26
PO Box 8450
Rome, NY 13442

Re: Sender Disapproval Notice

To Whom It May Concern:

We are in receipt of your Sender Disapproval Notice for the publication Tip of the Spear sent to your facility, dated January 5, 2024, enclosed within.

The listed reason for censorship is that the publication allegedly satisfies guidelines D and E of the Sender Disposition Notice Guidelines which state that a “publication which advocates and presents a clear and immediate risk of lawlessness, violence, anarchy, or rebellion against governmental authority is unacceptable” and that publications should not “advocate, expressly or by clear intention, acts of disobedience.”

As distributors of Tip of the Spear, we know that no material fitting any of these descriptions can be found anywhere in the publication. Furthermore, please refer to Crofton v. Roe, 170 F.3d 957 (9th Cir. 1999) where the courts found that when censoring publications on the basis of security concerns in prisons, it is unacceptable when authorities do not, “attempt to explain in what way publications, by any particular characteristics of their own, threaten security or contribute to other problems the state asserts the regulations are designed to avoid.”

We request the decision to withhold Tip of the Spear be vacated and the publication be forwarded to its intended recipients. Failure to provide appropriate notice and adherence to your policies may result in legal action.

Please govern yourself accordingly.


Sincerely,

pages 85-92 is depicting or describing techniques or methods for rioting and/or information in hostage or riot negotiation techniques